Albany Vacancy Study Reveals Woefully Outdated State Law on Adopting Rent Stabilization

“It is clear to everyone that there is a housing emergency in the City of Albany, yet the state law prohibits the city from implementing proven policies to stabilize housing affordability”

NEW YORK  – The City of Albany released a long awaited vacancy study to determine eligibility for declaring a housing emergency under the Emergency Tenant Protection Act. The City’s study, which began in April 2024, ultimately found a vacancy rate of 8.33%, above the 5% threshold in the law to adopt the state’s rent stabilization system.

The statement below can be attributed to Housing Justice for All Coalition Director Cea Weaver: 

“It is clear to everyone that there is a housing emergency in the City of Albany, yet the state law prohibits the city from implementing proven policies to stabilize housing affordability. 

“It’s long past time to modernize the 50 year-old Emergency Tenant Protection Act for upstate New York by eliminating the barrier of a costly and flawed study, and allowing municipalities to determine what buildings will be covered in their jurisdiction.” 

The following statement can be attributed to United Tenants of Albany Executive Director Canyon Ryan: 

“Rents keep rising and rising, but conditions in our homes are not improving. It’s getting harder and harder to find a place to live. I appreciate the City of Albany’s efforts to confront the housing emergency, which we can all agree is threatening our community, but it can’t stop here. The City must remain committed to funding a renewed study and join efforts to reform state law to ease this process to give the city the tools it needs to stabilize rents.”

Background:

The Emergency Tenant Protection Act (ETPA) of 1974 is state law that governs rent stabilization. ETPA is enabling legislation that allows local governments facing a “housing emergency” – defined as a vacancy rate of less than 5% – to prevent price-gouging and displacement by controlling rent increases on buildings with 6 or more apartments. Between 1974 and 2019, ETPA was only applicable in New York City and its surrounding counties; in 2019 the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act amended the ETPA to allow municipalities outside of NYC and the surrounding counties to “opt-in” rent stabilization if the localities. 

Under the law, municipalities must determine via a study that the vacancy rate of buildings eligible for stabilization is less than 5%. These studies have proven to be a costly barrier to municipalities seeking to stabilize out-of-control rental markets, and have been a boon to litigious landlords opposing rent stabilization. The Hudson Valley Property Owners Association sued the cities of Kingston, Newburgh, and Poughkeepsie over the methodology of their vacancy studies, and filed a federal lawsuit against a 2023 law to standardize the study methodology.

The City of Albany initiated its vacancy study in April, conducted in-house by the Department of Neighborhood & Community Services, which sent multiple mailings and follow up calls to landlords to receive responses. Unlike other studies, the City spent a significant amount of time and resources determining the veracity of landlord claims of being exempt from the ETPA. 71% of respondents to the survey claimed they were exempt for one reason or another, size of the building, subsidized funding sources, or the much murkier “substantial rehabilitation.” The study was limited to buildings built before 1974 with 6 or more units, as required by the ETPA, which constitute just 14.6% of rental properties in the city. As the City of Albany’s study notes, “our own experiences and regional research suggest there is still a housing crisis in the City of Albany, just not one eligible for rent stabilization under NYS law.”

Housing Justice for All proposes modernizing the ETPA law to allow municipalities to declare an emergency and stabilize rents based on public hearings as well as publicly available data such as the overall housing supply, rent-to-income ratios, local or regional homelessness rate. This will both eliminate the need for a time-intensive, costly, and contentious vacancy study and will give local governments more flexible jurisdiction over their housing policy – allowing them to apply ETPA more appropriately. 

Scroll to Top